Sunday, December 3, 2023
HomeNewsDutch appeals court docket prohibits border police ethnic profiling

Dutch appeals court docket prohibits border police ethnic profiling


THE HAGUE, Netherlands — An appeals court docket on Tuesday prohibited the Netherlands’ navy police from utilizing racial profiling as a method of choosing folks for identification checks at borders, marking a victory for 2 residents and rights teams who sued the federal government.

The Hague Courtroom of Attraction overturned a 2021 ruling that mentioned ethnicity may very well be one of many standards for singling out passengers, however not the one one. The checks are carried out at airports and on trains and buses from European Union locations to forestall folks illegally coming and staying within the Netherlands.

The enchantment court docket mentioned in a press release that it discovered that the police, referred to as the Marechaussee, “makes a distinction on the idea of race. Given the intense penalties of discrimination on grounds of race, such discrimination ought to solely be made if there are notably compelling causes. The State has not demonstrated such compelling causes.”

The court docket mentioned it “subsequently prohibits the State from making choice selections which can be (partly) based mostly on race” throughout border checks.

The case was introduced by two residents who argued that they have been singled out for checks by officers from the nation’s Marechaussee police pressure due to the colour of their pores and skin.

One of many plaintiffs, Mpanzu Bamenga, a metropolis councillor from Eindhoven who was born in Congo, mentioned after the unique ruling in 2021, each time he returned to “my nation, the Netherlands, I’m being stopped due to my ethnicity.”

On Tuesday, he was jubilant on the court docket’s ruling.

“That is discrimination, it’s ethnic profiling,” he mentioned in a phone interview. And it’s so fantastic to see that the upper courts mainly acknowledge it. And for me, as a human being, it’s so good to see that justice has prevailed.”

The Marechaussee mentioned after the 2021 court docket case that it might change the way in which it really works at border checks, however the appeals court docket mentioned it noticed “no or solely restricted change in working technique.”

Marechaussee spokesman Maj. Robert van Kapel mentioned the group would fastidiously research the ruling “and see what its penalties are for now.”

The group has the choice to enchantment the ruling to the Supreme Courtroom.

Dionne Abdoelhafiezkhan of the Dutch rights group Controle Alt Delete mentioned the court docket ruling “additionally makes it clear that somebody’s look and colour say nothing about somebody’s nationality. That’s an essential correction to the court docket’s earlier ruling that shocked many individuals of colour and made us really feel like second-class residents.”



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments